Sorry to say it man but like every game on the SNES worth playing is probably over $30 in the current retro gaming climate. I'll do my best though.
Super Mario All Stars is a Must
Super Mario World
SMW2 Yoshis Island Probably (Never played it personally)
Super Bomberman (Super Bomberman 3-5 but you have to import those. Modding your SNES is easy. I hear Super bomberman 2 is shit. I've only played 1 and 5)
Bomberman B Daman (wait for my review it might not be for you)
Alien VS Predator
Donkey Kong Country 1 -3
Earth Worm Jim (Sega CD is best version and I hear Genesis version is better than SNES but I grew up with the SNES version)
Earthworm Jim 2
Final Fight Guy if you want to play as Guy
Knights of the Round. Fuck yeah.
Maui Mallard in Cold Shadow (Was originally Donald Duck, still is in Euro version I believe)
Mario and Wario if you get a SNES mouse
Star Trek Starfleet Academy if you like Star Trek
Super Gameboy for sure
Super Metroid if you can find it for the right price
The Lost Vikings
The Lost Vikings 2
Zombies Ate my Neighbors
I just went through my spread sheet and recommended shit as I saw it. I skipped over some of the more pricey games.
I'm also working on the next podcast like right this second so I'll be reading this list off on the show. Also if you don't mind my asking how much did that SNES run you?